Your First Apartment: What Nobody Tells You (And What Property Managers Actually Look For)

Renting your first apartment is exciting. It’s a major milestone—your own space, your own rules, your own independence.

But here’s the part no one really talks about:

Your first apartment also comes with a learning curve.

At All County® Property Management, we work with renters every day across the United States—many of them first-time renters. We’ve seen the most common surprises, misunderstandings, and “I wish someone told me this sooner” moments.

So if you’re getting ready to rent your first apartment, this guide will help you feel confident, prepared, and ahead of the game.

---

The First Thing Nobody Tells You: It Costs More Upfront Than You Think

Most first-time renters plan for the monthly rent.

But what surprises people is the move-in cost.

In most cases, you may need to pay:

• First month’s rent

• Security deposit

• Application fee

• Pet fee or pet deposit (if applicable)

• Administrative or lease fee (depending on the property)

A good rule of thumb:

You should plan to have 2 to 3 times the monthly rent available before move-in day.

This doesn’t mean you need to be wealthy—it just means you need to be prepared so you aren’t caught off guard.

---

Let’s Talk About Security Deposits (Because They Confuse Everyone)

A security deposit is not a “bonus payment” or extra rent.

It’s a deposit held to help cover:

• Damage beyond normal wear and tear

• Unpaid rent (if applicable)

• Excessive cleaning

• Lease violations that cause financial loss

What most renters don’t realize:

Your security deposit is something you can usually get back—as long as you treat the property responsibly and follow move-out instructions.

Pro tip from property managers:

When you move in, take photos of:

• Floors

• Walls

• Appliances

• Bathrooms

• Any existing marks or damage

Then keep those photos saved.

That one step can protect you later.

---

The “Rental Resume” Is Real (Even If You’ve Never Heard That Term)

When you apply for an apartment, you’re essentially being reviewed like a job applicant.

Property managers are looking for signs that you will:

• Pay on time

• Take care of the property

• Communicate respectfully

• Follow the lease terms

At All County®, our goal is to approve qualified residents quickly and fairly—while also protecting the property owner’s investment.

---

What Property Managers Actually Look For

Here are the most common things we review during the application process:

1) Income

Most rentals require that the household income meets a certain threshold.

A common standard is:

• 2.5x to 3x the monthly rent in gross monthly income

This helps ensure your rent is affordable and sustainable—not stressful.

---

2) Employment Verification

This doesn’t mean you need the “perfect job.”

But we typically look for:

• Stable income

• Verifiable employment

• Clear documentation (pay stubs, offer letters, bank statements, etc.)

If you’re newly employed, that does not automatically disqualify you.

---

3) Credit

Credit is one of the biggest stress points for first-time renters.

But here’s what many people don’t understand:

Credit is not always about being “good” or “bad.”
It’s about showing patterns of responsibility.

Property managers may review:

• Payment history

• Collections

• Past evictions

• Outstanding debts

• Bankruptcy (depending on how recent)

Important note:

If your credit isn’t strong yet, that does NOT automatically mean you can’t rent.

There are options.

---

4) Rental History

If you have never rented before, don’t panic.

We understand that everyone starts somewhere.

If you don’t have rental history, we may look at:

• Employment history

• Previous living situation

• References

• A guarantor (more on this below)

---

5) Background Screening

Most professional property management companies screen for safety and lease compliance.

This is standard across the industry and helps protect:

• The property

• The neighbors

• The community

---

What If You Don’t Qualify? That Doesn’t Mean You’re Out of Options.

This is one of the most important parts of this blog:

Just because you don’t qualify on your own doesn’t mean you can’t rent an apartment.

It just means you may need a different approval path.

Depending on the property and the owner’s requirements, options may include:

• A guarantor

• Additional deposit (where legally allowed)

• A co-signer

• Proof of savings

• A roommate who qualifies (if allowed)

Every property is different, but the key is:
Don’t assume you’re denied forever. Ask what options are available.

---

What Is a Guarantor (And Why It Helps)?

A guarantor is someone who agrees to be financially responsible for the lease if the tenant cannot pay.

This is extremely common for:

• First-time renters

• College students

• Young professionals

• People rebuilding credit

• Renters who are newly employed

A guarantor is typically:

• A parent

• A relative

• A trusted adult with strong income and credit

Here’s what a guarantor does:

They reassure the property owner that rent will still be paid if something unexpected occurs.

What a guarantor usually needs:

• Strong credit

• Verifiable income

• A clean rental background

---

Renter’s Insurance: The Most Overlooked (And Most Important) Thing

Many first-time renters assume the landlord’s insurance covers their belongings.

It does not.

Landlord insurance typically covers:

• The building structure

• The owner’s liability

Renter’s insurance covers:

• Your personal belongings

• Your liability (if you accidentally cause damage)

• Temporary housing in some cases (loss of use)

And here’s the surprise:

Renter’s insurance is usually very affordable.

Many policies cost around $10–$25 per month, depending on location and coverage.

For the price of a few coffees, you can protect:

• Your furniture

• Your electronics

• Clothing

• Jewelry

• Kitchen items

• And more

Find out what you need to know about renters insurance.

---

Utilities: What You’ll Probably Need to Set Up (And Budget For)

This is another huge “nobody told me” moment.

Depending on the rental, you may need to set up:

• Electricity

• Water/sewer

• Gas

• Trash

• Internet

• Cable (optional)

Also: deposits.

Some utility companies require a deposit if you:

• Have limited credit

• Have no utility history

• Are new to the area

That’s normal.

---

Your Lease Is Not “Just Paperwork”

A lease is a legal contract. And for first-time renters, it can feel overwhelming.

But here’s what matters most:

Things you should ALWAYS understand before signing:

• Rent due date and late fees

• Maintenance request process

• Guest policies

• Pet rules

• Parking rules

• Lease renewal terms

• Early termination rules

• How to give proper notice to move out

At All County®, we encourage renters to ask questions. A professional property manager should never make you feel rushed or embarrassed for wanting clarity.

---

Maintenance: How to Get Help the Right Way

One of the biggest mistakes first-time renters make is waiting too long to report an issue.

If you notice:

• A leak

• A small mold spot

• A running toilet

• An appliance acting up

Report it early.

Small issues can become big problems if ignored—and reporting promptly protects both you and the property.

---

Your First Apartment Should Be a Positive Experience

Renting your first apartment is a big step. It’s also a learning experience—and you don’t need to have everything perfect to get started.

At All County® Property Management, we work with renters from all walks of life across the country. Our goal is to help residents find a home, understand expectations, and enjoy a smooth rental experience.

If you’re applying for your first apartment and feel unsure about credit, employment history, or deposits, don’t assume you can’t qualify.

Ask questions. Explore options. And work with a professional team who will guide you through the process.

---

Ready to Rent? We’re Here to Help.

All County® Property Management helps renters find professionally managed homes across the United States—with clear lease terms, responsive maintenance, and support throughout your lease.

Whether you’re renting your first apartment or your fifth, our team is here to help you feel confident every step of the way.

To find your next rental property in your neighborhood, visit All County today!